Gandhiji could have saved Sukhdev, Bhagat Singh and Rajguru

23 Mar 15
Written by
Published in Indian History

On Hutatma Diwas we pay our tributes to the great freedom fighters Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev & Rajguru.

They were hung to death for avenging the murder of Lala Lajpat Rai, (a Hindu Mahasabha founder member). It's believed Gandhiji could have stopped their hanging, so why didn't he ?

Bhagat Singh was only 24 when he was hanged. It could have been stopped by Gandhi. But Gandhiji was not sincere in his efforts for reasons of his own. Gandhi could have put pressure on Irwin to release Bhagat Singh. Irwin & Gandhi were very close. So close that Irwin had forced a temporary truce on the freedom movement. However, he sent S Shastri, T B Sapru & M R Jaykar to plead wih Irwin.

Gandhiji seemed to believe that if Bhagat Singh lived on, his idea of "non violent" movement would get challenged.  So it is alleged that he did not do enough to stop their hanging.Gandhiji,  in fact, told openly that militant movement was harmful to "India's freedom movement".

Although Gandhiji, on popular pressure,  did write to Irwin on the day of the execution, pleading to have mercy on the three revolutionaries but as anyone would expect -  the letter would be too late.
 
Some believe Gandhiji was mortified that the revolutionaries of India had rattled the British. Moreover, and more importantly, revolutionaries had shown to Indians that the colonial rule could be overthrown by force and bravado. Apparently that was not acceptable to Gandhiji (So much so that his role was criticized in the 1931 Congress Session by congress itself) who vehemently advocated non-violent means for achieving the dominion status for India ( There is a belief that, GandhiJi was happy with dominion status. Rise of the revolutionaries and aggressive campaign by the rising Garam-Dal leadership forced him to campaign for "Poorn Swarajya" (Total Independence).
Also, as one would expect - Nehru played a key role in further pushing Gandhi in not taking a hard stance against the execution of Bhagat Singh. Nehru too was afraid that militant movement in the Congress led by Subhash Bose would overtake him & Gandhi- and reducing them to irrelevant members. So Nehru did what was necessary for safeguarding his political interests.  Irwin knew about the power struggle between Bose & Nehru-Gandhi. Irwin told Nehru to ask Gandhi to go soft on the execution. That is the story of how Gandhi & Nehru became complicit in getting Bhagat Singh & Comrades hanged by the British.

Gandhi later said, "Rajguru, Sukhdev and Bhagat Singh did not wish to live. They refused to apologize, or even file an appeal."

13 comments

  • Comment Link unfiffefmattyfish70 Tuesday, 07 March 2017 11:19 posted by unfiffefmattyfish70

    Often this second trick normally takes some hit and miss out on practice.? I guess there? ll be quite a few sacrifices,? she replied, and looked around around the crowd.usa MySpace Comments How to employ a B2B Business list to advertise your new business For today? s market a lot more businesses are looking to be able to business to business or B2B e-mail lists to entice more leads.It's found that those using animal companionship reduced the particular increase in blood pressure that had stress by half.Looking for month of practice WHEN I realised my techniques were being working? my hair impairment had dramatically reduced.
    They're also prone to a many types of health problems a result of reckless breeding.There are several shopping cart software programs available for this very purpose 2.all of us MySpace Comments Role And Duties Within the Criminal Defense Attorney On Houston, Texas The Houston defensive lawyer? s role in criminal cases is always to zealously represent his clientele within all legal and ethical bounds.To include insult to idiocy, the latest polls indicate that almost all Iraqis think their nation may be more peaceful if coalition troops would depart immediately.Temping at an agency can be a clever way to obtain your dream job.
    Mainly in these economic circumstances, it would be the single most important lessons in their life to be taught about the value of money in their young years.u . s . MySpace Comments Boys Toilet Training: Treat Your Child Together with Love And Care Teaching your son basic principles of potty training is certainly both a fun together with, well, what can WHEN I say, ' interesting' past experiences, since children don' t really like to stick to rules.In actual fact Traffic Dashboard creator, Betty Roach, specifically warns that men and women fake oakley
    who usually put up crappy contents ought not even bother buying Traffic Dashboard course given that the impressive Traffic Dashboard example results were only obtained with world class articles.Take heart because while marketing is truly complex, it is not difficult.There is largely simplified the tremendously complicated connections of home entertainment system system by merging a digital video and mp3 signal into one (cable).
    Within the animal kingdom, alphas are those who are leaders of the group, to whom the others stick to and defer.Intended for comments and inquiries regarding the article visit: About The writer Janice Jenkins is a writer for a marketing company in Chicago, IL.As people and as a community, it is important to unite and have a home in an eco-friendly community therefore, the next generations can also be able to enjoy earth? s bounty.Don't ever overlook team work and creating a strong team that knows easy methods to work together because this is the simplest way to fail with this kind of business.If the worst comes to the item, then you? ve still got the amount of money from the advance flights.
    Related Articleshttp://www.helovia.net/forum/showthread.php?tid=761408
    http://bbs.liyingd.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1786891&extra=
    http://bbs.moxing.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=8911&extra=
    http://www.saabing.com/board/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=297832
    http://szpuyou.net/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=730900&extra=
    http://archive.tcltk.co.kr/punbb/viewtopic.php?pid=781454#p781454
    http://trinitynetworks.org/fluxbb/viewtopic.php?pid=2501887#p2501887
    http://bokraa7la.net/vb/showthread.php?4260-%D0%B2%D1%81%D0%B5-%D0%B4%D0%BB%D1%8F-%D1%84%D0%BE%D1%82%D0%BE%D1%88%D0%BE%D0%BF%D0%B0&p=361221&posted=1#post361221
    http://202.143.141.248/khogjeam/index.php?topic=503642.new#new
    http://www.forum.ptcnr.xyz/viewtopic.php?pid=383667#p383667
    http://forum.supertankwars.id/showthread.php?tid=720741
    http://bit-cloud.net/forum/index.php?topic=735416.new#new
    http://youliaow.com/thread-221034-1-1.html
    http://www.fangmazhou.com/thread-165658-1-1.html
    http://lsyu.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=34771&extra=

  • Comment Link TY Thursday, 02 March 2017 09:28 posted by TY

    For anyone reading this article, read this one as well. http://www.mkgandhi.org/articles/bhagat_singh.htm

  • Comment Link avs Tuesday, 21 February 2017 16:19 posted by avs

    evidence is all there. lazy and shameless people do not want to face facts.

  • Comment Link Dvd Friday, 17 February 2017 12:24 posted by Dvd

    Nehru was a selfish politician always. He and Gandhiji together kept a soft hand on the 'Fansi' of our brave heros. just to save their political carriare mainly Nehru was a culprit. I would also say that it wasn't only Gandhiji who gave India freedom it was BHagatsingh and his companions who shown britishers our strength of fighting. I don't want to say any bad thing about Gandhiji but the facts that we know are forcing me to think such so. The same thing happened again at the time of India's freedom. Gandhi ji would have made "Shri Sardar Vallabh BHai Patel" the loh purush our P.M. but instead of it ge made nehru our P.M. and it was really "Independent India's" bad luck that corruption placed it's feets from the beginning. just because of a single wrong step we are the "Third World" today.

  • Comment Link Sajneet kaur Sunday, 05 February 2017 04:42 posted by Sajneet kaur

    Traitor gandhi!!!!!

  • Comment Link Smitha62 Monday, 16 January 2017 08:10 posted by Smitha62

    Article Source a viral game app is not that much egkdeedbcceekceg

  • Comment Link Ashish Wednesday, 11 January 2017 14:09 posted by Ashish

    Could be achieve freedom by choosing soft path?? A strike was needed against British Empire which was initiated by Bhagat singh.

    We are proud of Bhagat Singh and Ashamed of Gandhi and Nehru.

  • Comment Link Atul Saturday, 31 December 2016 22:44 posted by Atul

    But truth is truth, Gandhi could have saved bhagat sukhdev and rajguru. Even we could have won the fight against many times but Gandhi was the biggest issue. Now we are are partitioned just because of his stupid suggestions.

  • Comment Link Rohit Kumar Monday, 21 November 2016 11:21 posted by Rohit Kumar

    I like Bhagat's Singh Ideology.

  • Comment Link Madhusmita Padhy Saturday, 12 November 2016 09:38 posted by Madhusmita Padhy

    Please don't spread such rumours and malign Gandhi's image. The least you can do is respect your history.

  • Comment Link bobby thakur Wednesday, 05 October 2016 05:13 posted by bobby thakur

    These are unseen stories thus cannot be trusted .without evidences we cannot believe anithing

  • Comment Link bobby thakur Wednesday, 05 October 2016 05:12 posted by bobby thakur

    These are unseen stories thus cannot be trusted .without evidences we cannot believe anithing

  • Comment Link bobby thakur Wednesday, 05 October 2016 05:11 posted by bobby thakur

    These are unseen stories thus cannot be trusted .without evidences we cannot believe anithing

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated. HTML code is not allowed.